All organizations face employment practice liability issues; however, non-profits commonly face additional or increased challenges because of their unique structure and functions. In fact, industry data shows that about 80% of Directors’ and Officers’ Liability Insurance claims made by non-profits are related to wrongful termination or discrimination. But don’t worry, there are a number of measures non-profit organizations of any size can make to lower their risk.

Employment Contracts

Ensuring the use of up-to-date employment contracts is paramount.

Not having a well-drafted and enforceable employment contract for all employees can cause numerous financial and legal problems.

All organizations should use employment contracts that include the following basic clauses:

  • A job description which includes the duties and responsibilities of the employee
  • The length of the probationary period (if applicable)
  • The duration of the period of employment (e.g. 6 months, 1 year, 3 years etc.)
  • Employee salary, and if applicable the bonus structure, and benefits
  • A termination clause

In order to ensure that employment contracts are enforceable, the contract should be signed before the employee begins their first day of work.

Termination

Non-profits are vulnerable to budget changes from year to year which can lead to the termination of staff in order to balance the books. Termination clauses in employment contracts are important because they can limit the amount of severance pay that the organization is required to provide to employees in the event that they are let go. With a proper termination clause, an organization can usually limit severance pay to a maximum of eight weeks’ salary. However, without an enforceable termination clause, the non-profit could be required to pay the employee up to two years of wages. 

This risk can be mitigated by having a lawyer draft a customized, up-to-date employment contract for new employees. Although there is an up-front cost to obtaining custom employment contracts, the financial risk of not having an employment contract with a well-drafted termination clause makes the cost worthwhile.

Constructive Dismissal

Due to lean staffing and potentially rapid changes in non-profits’ funding bases and short-term project goals, non-profits should be especially aware of the potential for constructive dismissal.

Constructive dismissal happens when an employer makes a substantial change in an employee’s responsibilities, location of work, salary, or other basic components of the employment relationship. If this occurs, the affected employee can resign and claim that they were constructively dismissed from their job. They can also claim severance pay in accordance with their employment contract.

Non-profits can reduce this risk by carefully drafting employment contracts and by offering compensation to employees if they are asked to take on additional responsibilities or to move to a new location.

Harassment

Due to the tendency for non-profits to have close-knit work environments, the absence of a well-staffed human resources department, and / or pressure to support high performing fundraisers, events and programs, non-profits commonly either lack formal workplace harassment policies or are prone to inadequate enforcement of these policies. In addition, non-profits often have volunteers join their organization who may not be aware of the organization’s harassment policies. Beginning with the #MeToo movement, these important issues are increasingly in the spotlight. If harassment happens at a non-profit, like any company, it can negatively affect the organization’s reputation and have legal consequences, both of which can affect the organization’s ability to accomplish its mission.

Non-profit organizations should ensure that they have a written anti-harassment policy that is freely available to all staff, volunteers, and board members. Regularly training staff and volunteers on the policy and ensuring that learning about the policy is part of the organization’s onboarding process for new employees, volunteers, and board members is also important. Finally, non-profits should ensure that there is a fair and reasonable process to follow when a complaint is made. In small or close-knit organizations where it would be inappropriate for another employee to receive a complaint or conduct an investigation of the complaint, the non-profit should use a neutral third party to handle this process, such as a Human Resources consultant.

Insurance

Directors’ and Officers’ Liability Insurance (D&O Insurance) provides coverage for a non-profit organization and their trustees, directors and officers who may be exposed to liability through the actions of a person (e.g. a Board Member) acting in their capacity as a member or representative of the organization. This includes claims arising not only out of the actions of directors, officers, and trustees, but also of employees, volunteers, and committee members.  Directors’ and Officers’ Liability Insurance is for when any error, omission, misleading statement, neglect or breach of duty, employment practice violation or wrongful act such as discrimination or harassment, is alleged against any person acting in their capacity as a member or representative of the organization.

Directors’ and Officers’ Liability Insurance also typically includes Employment Practices Liability (EPL) Insurance which provides coverage for wrongful acts arising from the employment process. The most common types of claims covered under EPL policies include:

  • wrongful termination,
  • discrimination,
  • sexual harassment,
  • and retaliation.

In addition, the policies cover claims from a variety of other types of inappropriate workplace conduct, including employment-related:

  • defamation,
  • invasion of privacy,
  • failure to promote,
  • deprivation of a career opportunity,
  • and negligent evaluation.

Organizations that are members of Volunteer Canada have exclusive access to a specialist D&O Insurance Program designed specifically for non-profit organizations. Coverage also includes Cyber Liability protection and more. For more information visit www.underourwing.bmsgroup.com

Legal Expense Insurance

Legal expense insurance (LEI) covers all the legal costs incurred in unforeseen legal events and fills the gaps that traditional D&O policies don’t cover. A wide range of legal expenses are covered, including lawyer and court fees, plus any adverse costs awarded by a judge. An experienced panel of lawyers saves you time and the stress of worrying about what’s next, whether it’s by answering your legal questions or handling your insured legal dispute. By purchasing your Directors’ and Officers’ insurance through the Under Our Wing insurance program, LEI will be automatically included in your insurance offering, as well as access to a free legal advice hotline.

Non-profit organizations are not immune to employment liability issues. It’s important for organizations of all sizes to proactively mitigate potential risks that can be financially costly and affect your reputation.

For more information or if you have any questions about Directors’ & Officers’ Insurance, please contact a broker at BMS on 1-844-294-2715 or at underourwing@bmsgroup.com.